Fall is NOT a good time to prune

Home / Gardening Tips / Fall is NOT a good time to prune


We’re wondering  about a Canada Red Bud Tree. We planted it last  year when it was a small size. It needs pruning now as it has long outward growing branches, no distinct main trunk. Do we need to wait till it blooms this year before we can prune? How do we encourage upward growth & a better shape?


Timing – If you can live without blooms for one year, it’s usually best to prune a tree in the spring while still dormant; ensuring you wait until temperatures will be above freezing for at least a day or two.

Not only can you clearly see the shape of the branches at this time, it’s best for the tree’s health to have such work done while it’s not bearing leaves or in growth mode.

You definitely do NOT want to do this pruning in the fall. Avoid creating a relatively new wound that will not heal well enough to withstand the cold winter elements. Fall pruning will result in additional die-back.

How to prune – here are a few basics to get you started:

1) Do not TOP any branches (lopping off an end) or it will spoil the tree forever.

2) Do careful pruning cuts very close to where a chosen branch meets another main branch or trunk but not slicing away an excessive amount of bark.

3) Don’t take more more than 30% of the branches or foliage in one year…that’s what feeds the tree and will help it recover.

4) Check for and remove any broken, rubbing, crossed or seriously weak crotches (V-shaped). These issues are relatively unlikely in a redbud but something to look for and deal with sooner rather than later.

5) To develop upright growth you need a strong leader (which you may encourage by removing competitors and loosely tying the chosen one with a soft tie and a stake).

6) Your second goal is to select which will be the strong, relatively symmetrical scaffold branches for the long term and protect them while gradually over next few years removing other branches. Consider also where you want the tree to start branching from …ie do you wish to raise the point where the tree starts branching out to allow underneath seating or perennials or a lawnmower to run under it? Keeping in mind point number 3, start pruning out those lower branches as needed. Don’t overdo it or you’ll get a top-heavy tree that’s more prone to breakage.




Pruning is an extensive topic. Here are a few resources to explore for more information:

University of Virginia – Guide to Successful Pruning of Deciduous Trees 

The Iowa Gardener – How to Prune a Small Tree

University of Minnesota – Pruning Trees and Shrubs